On site a trip is usually reported in one sentence, yet behind that sentence there may be four different levels of action. A motor that overheats trips the thermal relay, a branch breaker trips the branch it protects, and the main breaker trips the whole machine. The handling and the protection logic are not the same, so the first thing to do is to work out which level acted.

The protection chain is layered

Working from the supply inwards: the main breaker feeds the whole machine, the branch breakers feed the heating, the pump sets and the control circuits, and the thermal relay sits at the motor winding, where it senses the current heat effect of the motor itself. Each level has a different object and a different operating characteristic, but on site what is usually seen is the cabinet door opening or one indicator lamp going out.

The nameplate total power of the ZYD series is 72 + 5 kW and the supply is three phase 380V / 50Hz. The distribution capacity, the breaker rating and the cable section are all matched to those figures, and if the current during operation goes clearly beyond what is expected, the one device in that chain that meets its operating condition first is what responds.

The two kinds of action differ

A breaker mainly deals with short circuits and severe overcurrent, and it operates fast; a thermal relay deals with a sustained modest overload, works on the accumulated heat effect of the current, operates with a delay, and the delay depends on how many times the rated current is exceeded. That explains a common observation: a motor carrying a little more than its load shows nothing for a while and trips later, while a short circuit in the line opens almost at once.

The phase failure and phase sequence protection is a separate chain. It deals with a supply that is not correct in itself, and it is not part of the overload protection. With a phase missing the motor may not start or may run at a reduced speed, and whether the thermal relay operates depends on the current in the two remaining phases and on the time, so this kind of fault cannot be left until the thermal relay has acted.

The arrangement of the terminals and the protective devices inside the electrical control cabinet
The breaker, the thermal relay and the phase sequence protection sit in different places in the cabinet and do different work
Device that actsWhat it protectsOperating characteristicWhat is seen on site
Main breakerThe whole machineShort circuit and severe overload, fast operationThe cabinet opens as a whole and the other circuits lose power as well
Branch breakerA branch such as the heating or the pump setA short circuit or an overload on that branchOnly one part of the machine stops while the other indicators stay normal
Thermal relayThe motor windingAccumulated heat effect of a sustained overload, delayed operationThe motor in question stops, and there may be a reset button in the cabinet
Phase failure / phase sequence protectionThe supply inputCuts off as soon as the supply is not correctThe motor does not run or does not start, and a phase sequence error is shown

Four questions to ask on site

  • Which level acted: look at whether the main handle has dropped or a single branch has opened, and whether the other circuits still have power.
  • Does it trip again after the reset: an immediate re-trip points to a sustained overload or a short circuit, while a trip after a while is usually connected with the load or with the temperature rise.
  • What did the ammeter read before the trip: compare the reading with the power on the nameplate, and a clear deviation means it was not a momentary disturbance.
  • What was the oil doing when it tripped: warm-up, pulling the vacuum or normal degassing, because the current differs from stage to stage.

There is one more chain that is not electrical

The acoustic and visual alarm with automatic shutdown on overpressure is a process interlock and does not belong to the electrical overload chain. When the pressure difference across the filtration stage rises or the outlet is blocked and the pressure goes beyond the set value, the machine gives the alarm and stops; what is seen in this case is the alarm first, not a breaker operating. Telling the two kinds of stop apart changes the order in which the machine is put back into service.

A trip is not a conclusion, it is four different levels of action; find out which level acted before asking why it tripped.